Transparency Lab · From the Lab

Convention 108+

Campaign to Convention 108+

Opening an international transparent security and privacy market is a critical moment in global governance

Canada has a chance, this autumn, to do something it has not done before: join the only binding international treaty on data protection that is open to the whole world, and bring to it the one thing the treaty still needs, a way for people to see that it works.

A treaty on the edge of force

Convention 108 was opened for signature in 1981. It now has 55 Parties, including nine countries outside the Council of Europe. Its modernised form, Convention 108+, enters into force once 38 Parties have ratified it. In September 2026 the count stood at 34.

Canada is not among them. It is not a Party to Convention 108 at all. That leaves Canada outside the one framework most likely to decide how personal data moves between democracies over the next decade.

Why it is a market, not only a law

Convention 108+ is usually read as a list of rights. It is also a trade instrument. Article 14(1) says a Party “shall not, for the sole purpose of the protection of personal data, prohibit or subject to special authorisation the transfer of such data to a recipient who is subject to the jurisdiction of another Party”. Countries that meet the same standard can stop treating each other’s data protection as a reason to block a transfer.

The European Union already reads it that way. When the European Commission decides whether a country protects personal data adequately, the GDPR says that “the third country’s accession to the Council of Europe Convention … should be taken into account” (Recital 105). Canada’s adequacy decision dates from 2001 and covers only organisations subject to PIPEDA. Bill C-36 is about to replace PIPEDA for the private sector. Joining Convention 108 would give that decision firmer ground at the moment its basis changes.

A shared standard creates a shared market: for data, and for the privacy and security services that make data trustworthy. Whether that market is a glass box or a black box depends on whether the person can see into it.

The week the two tracks met

On 29 October, Bill C-34, the Safe Social Media Act, went to the House of Commons Heritage committee. It will make age checks online a legal duty. The next day, Canada and the European Union signed a joint statement committing both sides to “coordinate efforts to advance the safety of minors online” and to work toward mutual recognition in “digital identity, digital credentials and trust services”.

Age checks will be the first identity check most Canadians meet online, and the first thing Canada brings to that table. As drafted, none of the three bills now before Parliament, C-34, C-36 and the lawful access bill C-22, requires that the person be told who is checking them, be given a record of the check, or have a route to challenge a wrong result.

Thirteen fixes, ten of them steps toward the treaty

In our WHiSSPR report on the three bills we set out thirteen one-clause fixes. Ten of them also bring Canadian law closer to what Convention 108+ asks of a Party:

The fixes do not finish the job. A country is invited to join only once its law in force gives effect to the Convention, across the public and private sectors (Articles 3 and 4). The federal Privacy Act, provincial laws and transfer controls in Bill C-36 all still need work. But the bills at committee now are where the direction is set.

The missing piece is transparency

Every data protection law already says what a person is owed: who the organisation is, the purpose, the legal basis, and how to exercise their rights. What none of them provides is a way for the person to see, at the moment their data is processed, that this was done. Across organisations and borders, compliance is asserted, not evidenced. A regulator sees the design of a system, not the event.

Transparency by default closes that gap without a new identifier or a new database. The person is shown who is asking before they are asked anything, and keeps a receipt that holds no identity, can be checked later, and supports access and challenge. Published international standards already describe the parts: ISO/IEC 29184 for online notices, and ISO/IEC TS 27560:2023, now under revision as ISO/IEC 27560, for records.

The proposed Internet Transparency Code of Practice (ITCoP) is put forward as the mechanism that ties these together for the Council of Europe: a public code that sets the transparency defaults a Party’s law can rely on. The Convention’s own explanatory report notes that codes of good practice “are not by themselves sufficient to ensure full compliance”. A code needs law behind it. Bill C-36 offers that route, with approved codes of practice and certification programs open to independent verification and public approval. Canada could approve a transparency code at home and offer it to the Council as a working example. Our white paper, An Internet Transparency Code of Practice for Canada, sets out what that code would contain.

What we are asking for

On 4 November we sent briefs setting out these fixes to the House of Commons Standing Committee on Canadian Heritage, on Bill C-34, and to the Standing Senate Committee on National Security, Defence and Veterans Affairs, on Bill C-22.

A critical moment

Treaties are shaped by the countries that join while they are being brought into force. Canada gave the world Privacy by Design. It can now help give Convention 108+ the thing that makes rights visible: an international market in which security and privacy are not only promised, but shown.

About

Mark Lizar is a Canadian standards expert, editor and author in digital transparency, notice and consent. He founded Transparency Lab, the research lab of Global Privacy Rights, based in Montreal, and contributes to the Council of Europe’s work on transparency under Convention 108+. He champions the implementation of Convention 108+ through age assurance standards and the proposed Internet Transparency Code of Practice (ITCoP), put forward as an implementing mechanism for the Council of Europe.

References

  1. Council of Europe, Convention for the protection of individuals with regard to the processing of personal data (Convention 108+, CETS 223), Articles 3, 4, 8, 9, 11, 14 and 15, and its explanatory report, para. 33. https://rm.coe.int/convention-108-convention-for-the-protection-of-individuals-with-regar/16808b36f1
  2. Regulation (EU) 2016/679, General Data Protection Regulation, Recital 105. https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2016/679/oj
  3. Commission Decision 2002/2/EC on the adequate protection of personal data provided by the Canadian Personal Information Protection and Electronic Documents Act. https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/dec/2002/2/oj
  4. Joint Statement: Canada and the European Union building together an Alliance for the Future, 30 October 2026. https://www.pm.gc.ca/en/news/statements/2026/10/30/joint-statement-canada-and-european-union-building-together-alliance
  5. Bill C-34 (45th Parliament, 1st Session), Safe Social Media Act, LEGISinfo. https://www.parl.ca/legisinfo/en/bill/45-1/c-34
  6. Bill C-36, Protecting Privacy and Consumer Data Act, LEGISinfo. https://www.parl.ca/legisinfo/en/bill/45-1/c-36
  7. Bill C-22, Lawful Access Act, 2026, LEGISinfo. https://www.parl.ca/legisinfo/en/bill/45-1/c-22
  8. ISO/IEC 29184:2020, Online privacy notices and consent; ISO/IEC TS 27560:2023, Consent record information structure.
  9. Global Privacy Rights, WHiSSPR Report: Age Assurance Across Bills C-34, C-36 and C-22, November 2026. https://www.globalprivacyrights.org/reports/whisspr-age-assurance-c34-c36-c22-2026.pdf
  10. Global Privacy Rights, An Internet Transparency Code of Practice for Canada, white paper, November 2026. https://www.globalprivacyrights.org/reports/gpr-white-paper-itcop-canada-2026.pdf

For media and press

Republishing. You may quote, excerpt or republish this article in full, unchanged, with the credit line below and a link to this page. Mark cuts with an ellipsis.

Credit line. Mark Lizar, Transparency Lab. Published by Global Privacy Rights. AI Undermark um:feec158f.

AI Undermark. This article carries the AI Undermark um:feec158f. It resolves at transparencylab.ca/undermark/feec158f.json to the publisher, the version, the reuse terms and a fingerprint of the published text. It is a Level 0 undermark: resolvable, not signed. It declares terms; it does not enforce them.

AI use. Retrieval, summary and citation with attribution and a link are permitted. Text and data mining for training is reserved under Article 4(3) of Directive (EU) 2019/790, declared in tdmrep.json and the reuse terms.

Interviews and comment. info@transparencylab.ca

AI Undermark um:feec158f · Version 1.3, revised 4 November 2026 · replaces um:20cf194a · Level 0, resolvable, not signed · reuse terms 1.0